Can perception be affected by perspective?
And vice versa, can a new perspective change our perception?
We look at both these questions through a picture which was featured as KBG-74 and titled A Spherical Delight.
But firstly, let us understand both the words as defined in the Oxford dictionary.
Perception: 'The ability to see, hear, or become aware of something through the senses' or the second meaning 'the way in which something is regarded, understood, or interpreted.' In simple words, perception leads to a mental image of a thing or someone.
Perspective: 'A particular attitude towards or way of regarding something; a point of view'. It also has a second meaning- 'the art of representing three-dimensional objects on a two-dimensional surface so as to give the right impression of their height, width, depth, and position in relation to each other.' In simple words, perspective is the way we regard something or our point of view.
Now coming back to the Contest picture which received enthusiastic response from the readers. All the readers assumed the two objects to be melons because of the enlarged picture as shown.
Whereas the two objects were actually dried up lemons plucked from our yard. See the two pictures below. Of course, both lemon and melon are spherical in shape and have the same alphabets!
Now, what would you attribute this error to? Perception or perspective? Perhaps it is both. Perspective error because the picture showed only a part of the lemons giving an inaccurate impression of its size; and perception error because our mental image of a lemon is greenish-yellowish skin but certainly not dried pigmented skin as shown in the picture. Do you see the interdependence of perception and perspective here?
Before we selected the picture of the dried lemons, we had not thought of this story. Our own perception got changed when we looked at the perspective of the readers. We came across a nice visual comparing perception and perspective. Credit goes to pediaa.com for the picture reproduced below.
Hope we have answered both the questions. Yes, perception can be affected by perspective and vice versa a new perspective can change our perception. Both aspects are important for individual and organisational performance, relationships, understanding, conflict management etc. Apologies if Ghumakkad sounded like a teacher. In real life he is both as depicted in his logos below.
It is fun learning together!
The Contest
KBG-74, the 74th edition of Kaun Banega Ghumakkad Caption Contest received more than 45 captions listed below.
No. |
Name |
Caption for KBG-74 Contest |
|
|
|
1 |
Ajai
Bhumri |
खरबूजा खरबूजे को देखकर रंग बदलें, |
2 |
Amandeep
Kaur |
Garmi
ke do anmol ratan! |
3 |
Bharat
Ladha |
खरबूजे को देख कर खरबूजा रंग बदलता है। |
4 |
BR
Natarajan |
You
do not need lush lemon when you have musk melon. |
5 |
C
Raghuram |
Rough
outside, sweet and soft inside. Mimic the melon. |
6 |
Deepak
Jena |
The
smiles of summer |
7 |
Deepak
Jena |
Can't
wait to grab |
8 |
Geeta
Bhargava |
Duniya
goal, hum bhi goal |
9 |
GR
Sreenivasan |
Keep
calm and carry a watermelon |
10 |
J
Ramamoorty |
Mouth
watering spheres. |
11 |
Jaishankar |
Life
may give you melons but you can always find the musk in them. |
12 |
LS
Bhargava |
King
of summer fruits |
13 |
LS
Bhargava |
An
Energy food for Summer |
14 |
Manju
Khaitan |
Most
optimum shape for a tree to reproduce. |
15 |
Neelima
Paroolkar |
We 2
are One. |
16 |
Peter
de Padua |
Two
Melons a week,no illness will seek! |
17 |
Poonam
Bhargava |
Who
minds the summer heat, |
18 |
Pradeep
Siwach |
Summer
rasagola |
19 |
PRR
Rao |
Elon
Musk or Musk Melon? What's in a name? |
20 |
Radhika
Sareen |
Twins! |
21 |
Radhika
Sareen |
Ready
for delivery |
22 |
Radhika
Sareen |
हम बने इक दूजे के लिये |
23 |
Radhika
Sareen |
तू चीज़ बड़ी है musk
melon… |
24 |
Rajendra
Singh |
Anar
ready to ripen or musk melon! |
25 |
Rashmi
Bhargava |
Thanda thanda cool cool! |
26 |
RB
Dhavare |
So close but no hatred! |
27 |
Ritu
Bhargava |
This spherical delight musk melon. is must in
summers. |
28 |
Ritu
Bhargava |
Hard
outside,soft and juicy inside is mast melon. |
29 |
Ruma
Purkayastha |
Melon-colic
in summer ? Never never !! |
30 |
Savita
Bhargava |
The
Twins |
31 |
Savita
Bhargava |
खरबूजा खरबूजे को देख कर रगं बदलता है। |
32 |
Shereen
Sultana |
If life gives you melons, juice it up! |
33 |
Sujata
Das |
You are one in 'melon' to beat the heat. |
34 |
Susmita
Ganguly |
Perfect Parenting Mantra - Soft and Cool Within. |
35 |
Unknown |
Must Melons ! |
36 |
Unknown-2 |
हर अंडे में से नहीं निकलता चूज़ा |
37 |
Unknown-3 |
Summer delight |
38 |
Vanita
Vandan Singh |
Summer Summer on the Sky, |
39 |
Veeky
Baths |
Awesome
Twosome! |
40 |
Vinay
Prasad |
Musk
melon, must melon! |
41 |
Vinod
Dhanuka |
Kharbuje
Ko Dekhkar Khabooja Rang badalata hai |
42 |
VV
Ramani |
Flavour
of summer |
43 |
Yogesh |
Garmi
mein rang |
44 |
Supradeep
Sen |
Delightful
musk melons! |
45 |
Praveen
Rengaraj |
Tastes
better than it looks! |
46 |
Prashant
Jadenavar |
Freckles
outside, delicious inside. Ignoring for looks isn't the best option. |
The Winners
Our Jury comprising of Prabhjoth and Neeta have selected the following four captions as KBG-74 Winners. We thank the Jury and congratulate the winners.
Ruma Purkayastha is an educator and wellbeing coach who learns something from her grand children everyday! She majored in psychology and was Principal of a leading school in New Delhi. Her caption 'Melon-colic in summer ? Never never!' was unique and conveyed the cooling and soothing effect of melons in summer. Ruma has won the KBG Contests previously also.
'Life may give you melons but you can always find the musk in them', was Jaishankar's caption which hooked the Jury. It conveys a deeper sense of musk melon and life. A former Colonel, he has won the KBG contests several times. A blogger and an adventurer, Jai loves nature and wildlife.
Sujata Das PhD, is an alumnus of BITS Pilani, Stanford and Waterloo Universities who runs her own business in Canada. In her spare time, she loves to teach different age groups of people. Sujata loves winter sports, travelling and creative writing. Her caption "You are one in 'melon' to beat the heat!" appealed to the Jury. She is a past winner of the KBG Contest.
Ramdas Dhavare is an alumnus of NIT Surathkal and IIT Madras. He is a Science enthusiast, with interest in Philosophy and teachings of the Ramakrishna Mission. After a short stint with Indian Navy, Ramdas went on to teach engineering for 30 years. He now enjoys being with his grand daughter in Pune. His caption 'So close but no hatred!' reflects his philosophical thinking of the two melons close to each other. He is a regular participant of KBG Contests but the first time winner now!
Thank you all the readers for your continued support. The 75th edition of KBG Contest is coming up next!
Stay connected to trigger your creative thinking.
- Harsh-the-Ghumakkad with Neeta Bhargava/ 3rd June 2022
Postscript:
Vinod Agarwal writes: "What a simple picture to tell how easily we are fooled. Imagine how we are fooled by our leaders, political or otherwise, without us realizing it using the same techniques of making things look bigger then they are and making them look like that they have the same texture. Great insight."
#perception #perspective #gardeningisfun #ghumakkadhb #ghumakkadharsh #KBG #kbg74 #kaunbanegaghumakkad #onlinecontest #takeabreak #captions #powerofobservation #craetivecaptions #sphericaldelight #homegardening #lemons #melons
difference.
ReplyDeleteसड़ा हुआ नीबूं और पका हुआ ख़रबूज़ा
Thanks for another perspective!
DeleteI find perception and perspective very much complimentary to each other and both always affect each other for giving a new version of the philosophy hidden.
ReplyDeleteThanks for augmenting our thoughts Doc.
DeleteAlone I am nothing, but together we become formidable which changes the perspective
ReplyDeleteThanks Sir for adding another perspective!
DeleteThat was some optical illusion Sir.
ReplyDeleteI'd never have guessed that these were lemons
More than the confusion, it set me thinking when all the readers assumed it to be melons! That's how the story was conceived. By accepting other's perspective, we can change our perception! Thanks Jai.
Delete